tl;dr: The Trezor One before v1.9.3 and the Trezor Model T before v2.3.3 were vulnerable to a remote ransom attack when entering the passphrase on the computer/phone. The issue affected all cryptocurrencies on the device. Users are advised to upgrade their devices before receiving any more coins.
A bounty was paid out by SatoshiLabs.
Trezor released a fix in Trezor One v1.9.3 and in Model T v2.3.3 on September 2nd, 2020.
I have been in regular contact with a KeepKey representative. They didn’t slate a fix for development yet, stating that they are working on higher priority items first.
I performed the attack successfully by interactively modifying Electrum, running on Bitcoin Testnet.
I am one of the main developers of the BitBox02 hardware wallet. The BitBox02 supports the use of optional passhrases (aka mnemonic passphrase, aka 25th word¹) for expert users. The passphrase is entered on the BitBox02 itself during the unlock process.
Passphrases can be used to create hidden wallets. They are not stored anywhere on the device and are not part of the regular backup or recovery seed. Every passphrase is valid and derives a unique wallet. Losing, forgetting or misremembering a passphrase leads to losing access to the wallet permanently.
Since entering a long passphrase on the BitBox02 keyboard can be a bit time-consuming, I was brainstorming about how to allow entering the passphrase from the host wallet instead (e.g. BitBoxApp or Electrum), in a secure manner. I was thinking that the passphrase should be sent to the device encrypted after the secure pairing is established, and that the passphrase would have to be visually confirmed by the user on the device.
As a long time Trezor-owner, I remembered using this feature often with the Trezor, and realized that I never had to confirm the passphrase on the device itself after entering it in the computer.
The KeepKey was originally derived from Trezor, and behaves the same way in this regard.
As a hardware wallet user, you should assume your computer and mobile phone are compromised, including any wallet software installed. That is the reason to use a hardware wallet in the first place.
Hence, it is important that the hardware wallet validates any input it receives from the computer. In this case, the passphrase should be confirmed with the user on the device before using it to derive the seed. The Trezor and KeepKey did not do this in the case of the passphrase entered on the computer.
As a consequence, a malicious wallet or a man-in-the-middle modifying data transferred via USB could send an arbitrary fake passphrase to the Trezor / KeepKey, and hold any coins received in this wallet hostage. The passphrase entered by the user could simply be ignored, and the actual passphrase used would be only known to the attacker.
If that happens, the Trezor and the computer wallet load normally, and the user has no way of noticing that an attack is ongoing, even if they use the hardware wallet flawlessly, verifying all receive addresses according to best practices. Receive addresses in the computer wallet match the address shown on the device as usual, but the addresses do not belong to the user: the attacker can lock access to them by withholding the passphrase needed to spend from them.
With some sophistication, the user wouldn’t notice that anything is off at all until the attacker blocks access to the coins, demanding a ransom for releasing the coins back to the victim.
Practically, the attacker could run a server from which the malicious wallet would fetch a fake passphrase every time the user unlocks the wallet, and stop serving the passphrase once there are enough coins in the wallet to be held to ransom. Without the passphrase, the user has no way of regaining control of the coins without the attacker’s cooperation.
Impact and severity
Since the attack can be performed remotely, it counts as a critical issue according to Shift’s security assessment guideline.
The attack scales very well: an attacker who has compromised lots of computers can run the attack in parallel on many victims, and wait to strike until enough coins can collectively be locked and held hostage.
Since the private keys for all cryptocurrencies (Bitcoin, Litecoin, etc.) are derived from the same seed and passphrase, coins from all cryptocurrencies can be locked up at once.
The attack is particularly dangerous for newly created wallets, but it is possible to attack existing wallets as well. For example, the malicious wallet could hold on to the account xpub from the previous session and use it to show the account as the user would expect it, and some additional tricks.
An obstacle to performing the attack at scale is that the user needs to have the optional passphrase feature enabled on the device to be vulnerable.
: In my opinion, the passphrase should never be called “25th word”, as it is misleading in two ways:
- It can be an arbitrary passphrase with numbers and special characters, it does not have to be one word.
- It could lead users to use a word from the official mnemonic word list.
In either case, brute-forcing the passphrase would become trivial.
Originally published at https://benma.github.com.
Swiss made 🇨🇭 security
We are the makers of the BitBox02 hardware wallet. Its secure dual-chip architecture reflects our values as a Swiss open-source security company: it enables the use of a secure chip for physical device hardening in combination with fully open-source firmware. Made in Switzerland, it inherits our deep appreciation of quality and privacy.
Learn more about potential threats to hardware wallets and how we prevent them in our extensive BitBox02 threat model.
The BitBox02 comes in two editions: the Multi edition that supports multiple crypto assets and can be used as a second-factor authenticator. And the Bitcoin-only edition, which features a radically focused firmware: less code means less attack surface which further improves your security when only storing Bitcoin.
Discover the BitBox02 and get one today, we ship worldwide!
Shift Crypto is a privately held company based in Zurich, Switzerland. Our international team of specialists across engineering, cryptosecurity and Bitcoin core development build the BitBox products and provide consulting services. The BitBox02, a second generation hardware wallet, equips individuals to easily store, protect, and transact cryptocurrencies. Its companion, the BitBoxApp, provides an all-in-one solution to securely manage your digital assets with ease.